Catalina
- Ketchup
- Avocado Oil (Grapeseed)
- Honey / Agave Nectar
- Worcestershire Sauce
- Red Wine Vinegar
- Soy Sauce
- Onion Powder
- Garlic Powder
- Smoked Paprika
- S & P
I found a recipe online and made a small test batch, not using the suggested ratios of ingredients, and it turned out really well. I used Avocado Oil which has little flavor. *For years I have confused this sweet, red salad dressing as being either Russian or French… and maybe that is because I think I have seen it mislabeled on various restaurant salad bars. But, I do like the sweet, red Catalina Dressing.
Thousand Island
- Mayonnaise
- Ketchup
- Onion – diced
- Pickle Relish
- Hot Sauce
- Vinegar
- Garlic – minced
- S & P
This may not be the original online recipe I used, but it is close enough to the ingredients. I made this dressing at home to go on my Pastrami Rachel Sandwiches and it “turns” the Sauerkraut just right. I have made this recipe several times and it turns out well.
Curried Mayo Remoulade
- Mayonnaise
- Curry Paste
- Small Capers
I first made this at home after having visited the Water’s Edge Restaurant for the first time several years ago, and having a Shrimp Po Boy Sandwich that had a curried remoulade dressing. I’m not sure of the actual ingredients, but these three items came close enough. At one time, I kept a small jar of this in my refrigerator regularly and put it on various sandwiches, not just seafood.
CATALINA DRESSING

The first time I made this I used the wrong amounts for several of these ingredients but it made the dressing better. I think I used twice as much smoked paprika as designated and this made the finished product a deeper red color. It looked beautiful, a shiny ruby red.